Hicks Bay Lodge offers a mixed experience for guests, with an average rating of 3.3 out of 5. Many visitors appreciate the stunning views and the friendly, accommodating staff, consistently highlighted in positive reviews. The lodge is well-situated on a hill, providing a serene atmosphere and easy access to the nearby beach and glowworm grotto. Guests frequently mention the delicious food, particularly the steak, although some note long wait times at the restaurant. However, the accommodation is described as basic and in need of maintenance, with recurring complaints about outdated facilities and cleanliness issues, including dusty rooms and broken appliances. While some guests found the lodge charming for its rustic character, others felt it was overpriced given its condition. Overall, Hicks Bay Lodge is a decent option for those seeking a peaceful retreat, but expectations should be managed regarding amenities and upkeep.

Hicks Bay Lodge offers a mixed experience for guests, with an average rating of 3.3 out of 5. Many visitors appreciate the stunning views and the friendly, accommodating staff, consistently highlighted in positive reviews. The lodge is well-situated on a hill, providing a serene atmosphere and easy access to the nearby beach and glowworm grotto. Guests frequently mention the delicious food, particularly the steak, although some note long wait times at the restaurant. However, the accommodation is described as basic and in need of maintenance, with recurring complaints about outdated facilities and cleanliness issues, including dusty rooms and broken appliances. While some guests found the lodge charming for its rustic character, others felt it was overpriced given its condition. Overall, Hicks Bay Lodge is a decent option for those seeking a peaceful retreat, but expectations should be managed regarding amenities and upkeep.